I just still don't think DellaSala "gets it".
He chose to go public with all this - "My editorial was needed to be written for my own sanity" - and continues to speak out.
My point - and I think John's, too - is not the substance of the disagreement between Axiom and AH about testing methods and methodology, but about DellaSala's decision to editorialize about their relationship. He claims to want reconciliation, while at the same time publicly calling out Alan over technical disagreements. To me, his behaviour has not been politically astute, and it certainly does not enhance his integrity or trustworthiness. If I were a manufacturer or potential site advertiser, this episode would be a very meaningful case study about how DellaSala handles relationships.
We are a whole community of "that guy" - StPatGuy