Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56404 08/03/04 09:24 PM
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 25
hobbyist
OP Offline
hobbyist
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 25
All this talk about using 2 bookshelf speakers as one virtual center channel has me thinking. Why isnt this a more discussed option in the HT community? It has the potential to:

1 - offer a more dispersed, smooth center channel signal (toe in, toe out options, one above and one below TV, etc)
2 - often cheaper than dedicated center
3 - significantly lower frequency response opportunity (in case of M3 vs VP150, at least)
4 - 4 ohm impedance (assuming wired in parallel) vs 6 ohms meaning more output (wattage), (a good thing if your receiver can handle the load)
5 - Sounds like a cool idea

There may be others as well. Would like to hear the downsides as you guys see them. I havent made a center channel purchase yet, and think this one needs to more exploring. TonyM made me start thinking about this - lets pick up from there! Thanks Guys, Jeff

Re: 2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56405 08/03/04 09:35 PM
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 1,056
connoisseur
Offline
connoisseur
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 1,056
Here are a couple that immediately come to mind:

1. Aesthetics - people are used to seeing a flat center channel in an HT application. The look of two vertical centers (even if they were no taller than a regular center) may strike some as weird looking.

2. Shielding concerns. While the M2 and M3 seem to be immune to this problem, it could cause a problem with lesser speakers.

3. Dead zones or null points - the center channel will aim right at the prime listening position, in a perfectly parrallel configuration. Having two speakers toes in or out may create hot zones or null spots where the signals cross. While this problem can be fixed by decreasing or increasing the amount of toe-in, the casual use may dislike having to monitor this center channel with regard to toe-in.

Keep in mind, though, that while this idea isn't discussed - another well marketed company (read the "BLOWS" cube system) has been selling a center channel cube where the top and bottom unit can be flayed left and right, respectively so as to capture a larger sweet spot in the center listening position.

Re: 2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56406 08/03/04 09:49 PM
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,424
connoisseur
Offline
connoisseur
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 1,424
The biggest downwall to this is power. Not ever HT set-up out there will be able to do a good job with a 4ohm load or simply driving 2 from one channel regardless of the way it's wired. As for the Pro's, you listed enough already. I honestly think the Pro's outway the cons but that may not be the same for everyone.

Re: 2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56407 08/03/04 09:52 PM
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 8,488
T
axiomite
Offline
axiomite
T
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 8,488
Thanks for starting this thread, Jeff. I have a somewhat related question.

Why the fixation on using the M2 as a VERTICAL center channel? I vaguely remember JohnK trying to explain why it sounded better that way, but cannot find the thread (anybody?). TonyM observed that the M2 placed horizontally sounded "funny".

Now, I understand that a single, small center is probably not as good as a double, small center due to power handling, attainable SPL, symmetrical imaging, etc. My question really relates to why it is inherently worse to use two M2's horizontally (end-to-end) rather than vertically (side-by-side or separated). Could any of those problems be overcome by rotating the tweeter 90 degrees and re-mounting it?

If this qualifies as a thread-jacking, I apologize. TIA.


bibere usque ad hilaritatem
Re: 2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56408 08/03/04 10:01 PM
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 25
hobbyist
OP Offline
hobbyist
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 25
TT - I think it is right inline with the intent of my post. If one is considering using 2 speakers as one virtual center, then placement becomes an important part of the consideration. I find it hard to believe that the sound would change by changing the vertical orientation, but I am willing to be convinced otherwise! jb

Re: 2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56409 08/03/04 10:36 PM
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 137
veteran
Offline
veteran
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 137
Hello Tomtuttle,

Hope you are well.

When I put the M2s on their sides, I also had to stick a couple of Reader's Digests under them because of the angled speaker sides to make the drivers fire forward instead of upward.

I found that the speakers on their sides lost some detail and soundstage, I think the tweeter being so close to the top of the TV was causing a problem, and that orientation also put the Vortex port very near the surface of the TV. The Vortex port is located right behind the tweeter on the M2i, so it is normally about 7.25" above the speakers base. When the speaker is on its side it is less than an 1" from the TV, I am sure that causes some kind of interference. Also, the magnetic shielding was not sufficient to shield them from the TV when on their sides, I could only achieve good shielding vertical and toed inwards.

The M2i sounds 10 times better in the vertical orientation.

Maybe if you had a stand to elevate them from the surface of the TV, then they would sound the same on their sides. Say a stand about 10 inches or so high with a shelf that is smaller than the speaker case, so that the shelf does not interfere with the sound like the TV does.

Hope this sheds some light on this discussion.

Later,

TonyM

Re: 2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56410 08/03/04 11:51 PM
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 8,488
T
axiomite
Offline
axiomite
T
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 8,488
TonyM,

Thank you for sharing your insight and experience. I was hoping that you would find this thread and contribute

I'd like to discuss the vortex porting issue a bit more also; thank you for bringing it up. Your conjecture begs another question - how much clearance do the vortex ports on the M2 need *in any direction* before the sound is compromised? It is intuitive that they would need significant clearance directly behind the port, but your observation suggests that clearance along the plane of the speaker side may also be influential. We all know that early reflections from placing a speaker directly next to a wall are bad; now we question whether those same interactions *behind* the speaker matter.

I'm also interested in your observation about the proximity of the tweeter to the TV. For me, the comparison is between a VP100 and two M2's placed horizontally. Driver compliment notwithstanding, it seems that the tweeter on the Axiom VP speakers is not farther removed from the top plane of their resting place than is the tweeter of a horizontally-oriented M2 (all are center mounted on a 7.5" width baffle). So, is it possible that getting that tweeter farther "up and away" from the top plane of the TV is beneficial? Fodder for assymetrical mounting of the VP tweeters?

For my personal situation, some of this discussion is academic. My center MUST be placed in a little hole/shelf under the TV. It's too narrow for a VP150, and too short for a vertical M2, hence my questions.

Here is a bad pic. The Center channel speaker goes below the TV in the middle of the bench.



Now, don't go trying to give me creative, non-WAF solutions. I've gone about as far as I can with HT, and anything that puts the center in a screwy place just isn't going to pass the straight-face test.

I'm basically resigned to the VP100, but Tony's experience and analysis of the crossover points really has me thinking.

Sorry for the long post. Thanks for the help and discussion.


bibere usque ad hilaritatem
Re: 2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56411 08/04/04 01:02 AM
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,854
R
connoisseur
Offline
connoisseur
R
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 2,854
tt - "resigned to the VP100". Let me make you feel better.

Here is my setup, which is similar to yours. I had the stand custom made before I knew anything about Axiom. The bays are each 20" wide.


Please note that a VP100 sits proudly in the middle bay, bottom. Nicely tilted up due to Ian's excellent design. Would I have gotten the VP150 if the sapce allowed? You betcha - it was "more stuff" and I'm a guy, so I needed it. However, after speaking to Joe at Axiom (in one of our 1/2 hour discussions) and exchanging emails with Alan, I was comfortable with my ordering the VP100. I have not been disappointed for a single minute with the thing.

It is terrific and the dialog is crystal clear - the point of the thing to begin with. My M60s also assist in creating a "false center" (or some such reference Alan used) and the soundstage is seamless. I tend to lean towards centers because they were designed to be just that. The M2 and M3 discussions vertical/side are interesting, but they are bookshelf speakers, that's why they aren't designated as centers. Please - no offense intended to the M2 faithful; I'm a big believer in whatever makes you happy.

I've also played with tweaking the db levels of the M60s and VP100. The difference in 1 or 2 db is surprisingly noticeable in making the pair or the center a bit more forward. When I've got something on that is mastered a bit oddly, I just tweak the settings for the duration of that piece, but it is rare occurrence. The VP100 shouldn't be viewed as a compromise. It is an excellent speaker and won't disappoint.

Whew, I got all sweaty there. Hope the input is helpful.

Re: 2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56412 08/04/04 01:31 AM
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 137
veteran
Offline
veteran
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 137
Hello TomTuttle,

Hope you are well.

Wow, that picture makes it look like you are very close to those M60s. Those are M60's yes?

Ideally I would think 2 feet or more of space would be plenty to let the Vortex port breathe side to side and to the back.

I am thinking the farther the better with the tweeter from any surface, those frequencies are very interactive, and will bounce around.

Unfortunately any speaker in a little alcove is going to be limited in soundstage and imaging. If you could put that VP100 on a short stand in front of the TV, I believe it would sound much better. Maybe only use the stand when you are actually using the HT, and then put it back in its proper WAF approved spot in the entertainment center when not in use.

Some companies utilize a 3 way center with a tweeter above a mid between two woofers. Supposedly to improve imaging.

Later,

TonyM

Re: 2 speakers as center channel? Pros and Cons
#56413 08/04/04 04:21 PM
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 8,488
T
axiomite
Offline
axiomite
T
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 8,488
Hello Tony,

Thank you.

Yes, those are M60's. The picture is somewhat deceptive; the seating position is ~11 feet from the speakers, and I do not feel too close.

The idea of a stand in front of the TV rack is one I have considered and abandoned. It's a non-starter with my wife, and I'm inherently too lazy to move boxes around whenever I watch or listen. Life is a series of compromises.

Ray, thank you very much for the picture and the rhapsody. Be sure to stay hydrated. I had not seen that picture before, and you and I are in the same boat in lots of ways relative to placement and the process that got us there. I also had my cart custom built (to similar specs, apparently) because when I got the TV, there was simply nothing else available that met my needs.

I'm going to be perfectly comfortable with the VP100, I know that. I had not even had the chance to question that decision before Tony started talking about that response hole between 80-95Hz. My Denon 1804 will not allow me to set the crossover independent for each channel.

Thanks again, gentlemen.


bibere usque ad hilaritatem
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3

Moderated by  alan, Amie, Andrew, axiomadmin, Brent, Debbie, Ian, Jc 

Link Copied to Clipboard

Need Help Graphic

Forum Statistics
Forums16
Topics24,940
Posts442,457
Members15,616
Most Online2,082
Jan 22nd, 2020
Top Posters
Ken.C 18,044
pmbuko 16,441
SirQuack 13,840
CV 12,077
MarkSJohnson 11,458
Who's Online Now
0 members (), 558 guests, and 3 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Newsletter Signup
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.4