I'm about half finished with some extensive testing to solve a heat issue on my Outlaw 770. Using 20 minutes of a CD and with a Fluke Mulitimeter 83 taking voltage readings on the 5 M80's and the QS8's, so far seeing interesting useage of watts per speaker for average and peaks. Will post the info if enough are interested...and I have proved my therory as to what the problem is with the 770 I think, will see if the tech agrees with me tomorrow.
I would like to see the results.
Give a man a tool and enough spare time and he'll find a use for it.
I'd be interested in your results as well.
I will third that Dennis, I'd be interested to see the results.
Tharkun, will those watt usage levels be accompanied by some information about SPL spikes as well?
Putting the watt usage into context with sound levels would be interesting indeed.
In reply to:
Give a man a tool and enough spare time and he'll find a use for it.
Speaking of which... I just deleted the .WAV file off my web server of what the psychoacoustical compression in MP3 throws away.
Bren R.
Still testing a few things, and yes, I have made notes of the SPL levels, mostly have bee in the 100-110 db range, and my Bengal cats seem to enjoy being in the middle of the listening area and following the sounds from speaker to speaker. lol
Oh MY, 20 minutes at a shot at 100-110db! How many cycles? Do the cats still purr? How can you tell? How can THEY tell? lol
Just kiddin'
I'd love to see the results along with a list of what listening material was used. More bass should = more power used
how are you taking current measurements? Since you do need Current to get power.
P= IxV
Or get I by voltage and resistance but you cant use the nominal impedance, or can you. I guess if you average the voltage, you can use the impedance since that is also an average of the reistance at the frequencies... Hey there ya go.. im driving myself crazy here
Brandon, a multimeter can measure voltage, amperage and resistance(rather than single-purpose voltmeters or ammeters)and power can be derived from the results by using Ohm's Law.
If you're listening to music (ie time-varying signals) don't you need to measure both current and voltage at the same time ?
John, that's the case for accurate power measurements. For example, NI points out
here that "simultaneous" voltage and current measurement is necessary. Depending on what the capability of the Fluke 83 is, I suppose that resistance measurements could be taken, then the various voltages, and an estimate of power arrived at by using P=V(squared)/R. We'll see.
Hey guys, lighten up. There's no need to bring mathematics into this. Just use your ears, please.
>>Depending on what the capability of the Fluke 83 is, I suppose that resistance measurements could be taken, then the various voltages, and an estimate of power arrived at by using P=V(squared)/R. We'll see.
If you're willing to treat the speaker as a constant impedence then only one of voltage or current is required. I guess the question is whether that is close enough for this purpose. The impedence varies with frequency, so depending on the content you could have power levels differing by 2:1 at the same voltage.
I guess as long as the signal is "typical music" you could measure voltage (across the speaker) and current (in line with the speaker wire) once by playing the same material twice, use those values to calculate average impedence (I'm gonna feel stupid if it's exactly "4 ohms"
) and then for the rest of the calculations use that average value plus voltage measurements.
V^^2 / 4 is sounding better and better all the time.
Sorry for not updating my post sooner, but the Outlaw issue has become a way more involved than I had thought it would be. But bridgman has it correct with "V^^2 / 4 is sounding better and better all the time" In the past several weeks I have invested over $8k in Axiom/Outlaw products, and I thought I would have more than enough power to run the five M80's, even at a rather high level at times. The 770 is having a problem doing that, and after trying all of the trouble shooting ideas from tech support at Outlaw, and being told that it was very possible that my M80's, two of which have 60' runs for speaker wire, could be demanding to much power and causing the left rear amp to go into thermo protection, I needed to find some way to test the M80's consumption and see exactly what was happening. Since I do not have a $50k of test equipment, my simple mind went with the Fluke I have and do a simple voltage check. I have been doing this for several days, differant source material, differant volume levels, swaping out the M80's to differant locations, so on and so on.
I really need to thank Alan, as he has spent several hours with me on the phone about this issue, and I have needed to learn a way more about the M80's than I wanted to. lol Once again, I'm waiting for a call this morning from Outlaw to see what they have decdied to do. I will post an update as soon as I have some sort of resolvement to the problem, all I know for sure at this point, it is not my Axiom speaker wire, banana plugs, or speakers. From my very basic tests, all of the Axiom products are staying within the specs, and not over driving the 770. Thanks for all of the interest, and will have some data when done. ;-)
yes, but i have yet to see one that can do all of those at the same time. I suppose he could play the music at a set volume and take the voltage readings, and then hook the meter up to measure current and then play the material again at the same volume. Im not sure how much current is needed to drive the speakers but i imagine its way over what the meter is rated for.
Will try to clear up any confusion on how I trying to prove to Outlaw that the M80's are not drawing more then the 300 watts @ 4 ohms, which is what the 770 specs state. I'm using the Fluke meter on the 400 ac range, attached to to the speaker, and then just to the 12ga Axiom speaker wire. The meter is set to record the max,min, and average voltage. The CD soruce material is played for the same length of time, at the same voulume levels. I have used the meter, and I know the resistance of each speaker wire when connected to just the speaker, the amp, and just length of each speaker wire. When I have the voltage readings from each sampling of music and the volume levels, I then use V^^2 / by which ever resistance to determine the wattage. As I stated before, this is the only way I have to do a wattage test, to try and show Outlaw the M80's are not over driving the 770, its strictly a heat distribution issue on the 770. Well the wattage useage I find may not be 100% totally accurate, its the only way I could think of to try and prove what is happening with the 770 in my enviroment. ;-)