Axiom Home Page
Posted By: SRP High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/27/19 04:39 PM
Greetings All!
I'm thinking maybe (no good reason really - other than I can afford to do so!) it's time to upgrade my M80V2s to M80V4s - wondering if anyone can expound a bit on the High Power option. I'm sure it's been discussed before - so a link to any threads would be helpful too.
I'm strictly Stereo (2 Channel music - no movies, TV etc). Have had but ditched various subs and am powering the V2s with an Outlaw RR2150.
Am still in love with the sound of these speakers, so this may be diminishing returns - but maybe not!
Thanks in advance!
Posted By: Mojo Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/27/19 04:56 PM
I upgraded from M80v2 to M3, M5, and M100v4. Read my product reviews for M5, M3, 160 and 800 and posts. They are completely different. On a different level.
Posted By: Mojo Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/27/19 05:26 PM
The RR2160 replaced your receiver and it looks awesome. I really wonder how it sounds. It's missing three things: Tidal, Spotify and Chromecast all integrated into it.
Posted By: bridgman Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/27/19 08:34 PM
Originally Posted By SRP
I'm strictly Stereo (2 Channel music - no movies, TV etc).

I don't know if anyone has had a chance to do side-by-side comparisons between HP and standard versions of the same speaker, but for 2 channel music speakers without subs I would be tempted to spring for the HP version. There is a $700 CAD price difference so not a no-brainer choice but definitely tempting.

On the other hand the standard M80 low end response is very good so one could argue that unless you are playing at high SPLs with a bigger amp in your future then the standard versions will arguably be just as good.

It would be nice to see how the low end frequency response curves differ between the versions (cabinet volume is the same but woofer characteristics are different) but it might take a trip up the sub-woofer tower to do that and it's not the greatest weather for testing speakers outside right now.

Sorry, thought I would have a more useful response when I started typing frown
Posted By: Mojo Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/27/19 09:00 PM
M5s, each with a single HP driver, sound better than M80v2 which of course have two standard drivers each. That's not just my opinion. It's also the opinion of four others who heard my system.
Posted By: SRP Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 01:37 AM
Shoot!

Now I'm sorely tempted to return to my Bookshelf roots (Boston A60s were my trusted companions for years).
I am sub-less, remember Mojo - so I wonder - will I feel low end deprived if I shift from M60/M80 to the M5HP - it seems like you were running a sub during your A/Bing?

Thanks to you both for your replies Mojo and Brigman - yes, helpful (if not maddening - but of course insanity/obsession is half the fun). Hmmm....
Posted By: Mojo Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 02:14 AM
I now have the m5 in the living room and the M100s in my main space. When I was powering the m5 with my 17 year old Denon, I needed a sub and port plugs. I replaced the Denon with a 2 channel pioneer and no port plugs and no sub needed. It's like a whole different system! What do you think of that?

With the M5s you need stands. The best way to kill their sound is to put them in a bookcase... Lol. The M5s are 5 dB less sensitive than my M100s. So make sure you have enough power. Of course if you want the ultimate in realism, pick up the M100s in refurb or b stock. But I'll tell you the M5s are close. Think of it this way, the M3s are on one end of the spectrum and the M100s on the other. The M5s are wayyyy close to the M100s. I keep saying the m100s are for the 1%.

If the m5 lacks bass in your system, it will not be the m5's fault but rather your electronics!
Posted By: Mojo Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 03:33 AM
How far apart are your M80s, how far away are you sitting, how far from the front walls and side walls are they?
Posted By: SRP Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 03:55 AM
M80's are 12' apart - I am at the apex of the triangle just about 11" from center. no side walls - backs are about a foot from rear wall - toed in 0-15ยบ depending on my OCD at any given time.

Right, I know the M5HPs will need stands - there is no bookshelf in the room - I am using that term loosely to differentiate it from the M60/M80/M100 form factor. My brother in law is an accomplished finish carpenter so I'll commission him to build matching cherry pedestals - the metal pipe aesthetic of the Axiom stands won't cut it with my better half.

If anything at an 8 ohm (yes?) load the Outlaw will have even less heavy lifting than it does with the M80s now - so I think my electronics are sufficient to drive the M5HPs to their full potential.

Your experiences with the M5 are very compelling, Mojo...so thanks!

Push comes to shove I can always relegate them to the TV room and push them with my old HK...maybe that'd give me a reason to watch TV!
Posted By: Mojo Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 04:13 AM
No side walls?
Posted By: bridgman Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 01:54 PM
Originally Posted By Mojo
M5s, each with a single HP driver, sound better than M80v2 which of course have two standard drivers each. That's not just my opinion. It's also the opinion of four others who heard my system.

For what it's worth, I had a similar experience with M5HP's vs M60v4's... although I would probably be even happier with the M5's sound if I could trade the bass bump for a bit less bass.

That said, there's a good chance the difference is at least as much cabinet & crossover (or even the room) as the HP bass driver but I don't know (yet).
Posted By: SRP Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 02:20 PM
re the side walls - you'd have to see the layout - left 8', right 10'.
The front and back walls are more of an acoustic concern - 13' apart and parallel - even slight toe in make a big difference/helps to disrupt the standing wave.
Listening to a 24bit vinyl rip of My Life In The Bush of Ghosts as I type - and I have to say these old M80v2s are so impressive - the idea that the M5HP could trump them is exciting...
Posted By: SRP Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 02:23 PM
Thanks for that input, bridgman. Yet to hear a dissenting opinion - seems the guys nailed it with the 5HP.
Posted By: Mojo Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 03:15 PM
John, since my experience with the Pioneer vs Denon, I wonder if your bass problem isnt related to your electronics.

SRP, reading your posts and understanding more about you and your layout, I highly recommend staying far away from any Axiom v4. I lived with v2 for 11 years and since I've switched, I can't pull away from it. I've become consumed by it. You will find yourself listening more and more until you just lay there like a lump, wasting away in audio nirvana until your loved ones place you in an asylum.

You will kick yourself for not upgrading earlier. And you will love them so much, you'll want to feed them the best signal possible.
Posted By: bridgman Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 05:04 PM
Originally Posted By Mojo
John, since my experience with the Pioneer vs Denon, I wonder if your bass problem isnt related to your electronics.

It's possible - I did notice what seemed to be a small improvement in bass when going from the HK 3470 receiver's built in amplifier to the Adcom power amp (a 555 mk2 IIRC) - but I suspect the room is still a factor despite my efforts.

We'll find out for sure when I get the LFR1100's set up... they have HP drivers, new-ish crossovers and a heavily braced cabinet.
Posted By: bridgman Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/28/19 09:32 PM
Originally Posted By bridgman
Sorry, thought I would have a more useful response when I started typing frown

Forgot to mention... when I decided to respond I had only read the thread title and I thought the topic was amplifier power.

I was expecting to be able to respond with something like "yep, I think everyone agrees that high power is a Good Thing".
Posted By: Mojo Re: High Power? What's the verdict? - 01/29/19 12:36 AM
John, a scant 3 months ago I paid no attention to high power. Then I got the v4 and started experimenting. Even with the hobbled external amp connected up to my Pioneer, I am now a convert. Power, power and more power is where it's at. My only concern now is how all this power is going to impact my hearing.
© Axiom Message Boards