3.1 Upgrade Advice

Posted by: Bayne

3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/26/18 09:33 PM

Greetings, Programs!

Iím hoping to upgrade my 3.1 setup this fall, and have been trying to decide which speakers would be the best bang for my dollar.

Currently, Iím running two M3ís, a VP100, and an EP175. My AVR is a Denon AVR-3808CI. Just bought the TV stand seen in the photo, and will be bringing up my turntable thatís currently in the home theatre.

Iíve been toying with the idea of going with a VP150 and a couple of M5HPís. The VP150 should improve the centre channel for normal TV viewing, and the M5HPís might be nice for listening to LPís with the addition of their midrange driver.

Any thoughts?

Keep in mind, my home theatre is a 7.1 setup with a couple M60ís, and VP160, 4 QS8ís and an EP500, so thatís where I watch anything loud and explosive.

Posted by: Adrian

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/26/18 10:00 PM

Any chance of raising the TV a bit and fitting a third M5 underneath? I'm not certain you'd gain much over the VP100 using the VP150.
Posted by: Bayne

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/26/18 10:43 PM

Originally Posted By Adrian
Any chance of raising the TV a bit and fitting a third M5 underneath? I'm not certain you'd gain much over the VP100 using the VP150.


Iíd like to avoid moving the TV up any higheróitíll move out of the ideal viewing height of the viewersís eyes at 1/3rd from the bottom of the frame.
Posted by: alan

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/27/18 11:06 AM

Hi Bayne,
I'd have to agree with Adrian on your not getting much improvement from the VP150 over the 100. If you like the idea of the M5HPs as your left and right mains, perhaps you should use one of your M3s as a center channel. It's far more neutral than the VP100 or the 150, and should blend smoothly with the M5s. Note that I've never heard the M5s, but I expect they are excellent. And you already know what a great natural-sounding center channel can sound like, since you already own the VP160.
Note also that during my years working for Axiom, I never liked the VP100, and the VP150 was what I'd call "adequate" at best. I always encouraged Ian to develop a no-compromise center channel, which the VP160 and VP180 certainly are.

Regards,
Alan
Posted by: Bayne

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/27/18 04:58 PM

This weekend Iíll play around and see if I can get any more height for the TVóbut my wife is being a bit stubborn about going higher. I fully understand what Adrian and Alan are saying, and would love to get my hands on a VP160 Mini as the full-size one in the home theatre is like a warm hug compared to the sound of the VP100.
Posted by: cb919

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/27/18 06:20 PM

Or 2xM22 and a single M2 for center to minimize the amount of rise needed for your TV. That was my previous setup which sounded great. I now run 3xM5 for LCR which is also great but makes for a tall center channel! Are you thinking of changing sub as well?

PS - Love the Tron reference!
Posted by: Bayne

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/27/18 08:59 PM

Originally Posted By cb919
Or 2xM22 and a single M2 for center to minimize the amount of rise needed for your TV. That was my previous setup which sounded great. I now run 3xM5 for LCR which is also great but makes for a tall center channel! Are you thinking of changing sub as well?

PS - Love the Tron reference!


Iíll be keeping the sub. It adds the perfect amount of bass for this room as is and was added just about 2 years ago.

I considered the M22ís, but like my M60ís so much that the thought of going without midrange drivers somewhere in there seems wrong.
Posted by: Gr8_White_North

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/27/18 10:31 PM

I have a similar tv stand and i welded some extension on to the brackets and raised it up a couple extra inches. Honestly you wont notice it i am sure, though i do have recliners so it works out fine. The 180 is only 9.5 inches high and imho thats the one i
would get though it is a bit long. They need one like the 180 but smaller imho. Bear in mind that the 180 slopes back more than the 160 which will give you a bit more room. I ended up building my own, speaker placement is a bit unconventional but it works excellent.

Posted by: Adrian

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/29/18 02:49 PM

M5s and a VP180 center would be an awesome combo...maybe more $$ than you want to put into a "Secondary System" though.
Posted by: Mojo

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/29/18 03:33 PM

Originally Posted By Adrian
M5s and a VP180 center would be an awesome combo...maybe more $$ than you want to put into a "Secondary System" though.


M5HPs with a VP160 would be awesome.
Posted by: Gr8_White_North

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/29/18 07:06 PM

Originally Posted By Mojo
Originally Posted By Adrian
M5s and a VP180 center would be an awesome combo...maybe more $$ than you want to put into a "Secondary System" though.


M5HPs with a VP160 would be awesome.


True the 160 is preferable imho but as seen in his pictures the height is an issue and the VP 180 has a steeper angle and is also slimmer
Posted by: Mojo

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 06/30/18 01:38 PM

Height is not an issue. Bayne can clear that crap off the bottom shelf, move his receiver down and make way for the 160.
Posted by: Gr8_White_North

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 07/01/18 12:20 AM

too low
Posted by: MatManhasgone

Re: 3.1 Upgrade Advice - 07/01/18 10:13 PM

Looking at the photo. why don't you just move the receiver to the right and then put the M3 on the same shelf as the reveiver? there is nothing writen in stone that a reviever needs to be center on the stand.