Get Free, Friendly, Expert Advice
Call 1-888-352-9466 or email

Designed and Manufactured in Canada Since 1980

Axiom Dolby Atmos 7.2.4 Cinema
Solarrdadd's 7.1 Apartment HT!
AxiomAudio Blog

Insider’s Sneak Peek: AxiomAeris

Axiom’s New Computer Speakers

Blind Listening Tests

Who's Online
4 registered (Mojo, jmone, Fatboycarney, ajcook), 47 Guests and 4 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
13,584 Registered Members
11 Forums
23,433 Topics
415,514 Posts

Most users ever online: 378 @ 02/24/13 04:33 PM
Top Posters
Ken.C 18030
pmbuko 16418
SirQuack 13369
CV 11586
MarkSJohnson 11375
Meanwhile On Facebook
Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#284908 - 01/02/10 02:16 AM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: fredk]
Ken.C Offline
shareholder in the making

Registered: 05/03/03
Posts: 18030
Loc: NoVA
I've heard that the M80v2s are actually much improved over some iterations of the tis, but since the v2 was a process over several years, it's hard to say how much improvement you'd really see. Axiom is constantly tweaking the speakers, so a v2 bought 2 years ago probably isn't quite the same as a v2 bought today.
I am the Doctor, and THIS... is my SPOON!

#284919 - 01/02/10 07:41 AM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: fredk]
roar Offline
old hand

Registered: 11/06/06
Posts: 65
Loc: Burlington, Ontario, Canada
onn - Your setup is the craziest axiom setup I've ever scene! Words can't describe it, I hope it sounds as good as it looks! Next time I buy a component and my wife gives me the stink eye I'm showing her your setup \:\)

#284920 - 01/02/10 08:01 AM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: roar]
grunt Offline

Registered: 12/04/06
Posts: 3569
Loc: Nirvana
 Originally Posted By: roar

Next time I buy a component and my wife gives me the stink eye I'm showing her your setup

Reading this forum with dyslexia can be fun. I was sure you said “Next time I buy a ‘competent’ wife . . .” and not what you really wrote.
3M80 2M22 6QS8 2M2 1EP500 Sony BDP-S590 Panny-7000 Onkyo-3007 Carada-134 Xbox Buttkicker AS-EQ1

#284921 - 01/02/10 08:43 AM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: roar]
onn Offline

Registered: 02/28/08
Posts: 971
Loc: Edmonton Alberta
 Originally Posted By: roar
Next time I buy a component and my wife gives me the stink eye I'm showing her your setup \:\)

Just don' tell her I'm single and probably for a reason or two \:D otherwise you won't get anywhere showing it to her.
Or do you mean you'll show her my setup to show how bad it can REALLY get? \:D
My system

#284926 - 01/02/10 11:48 AM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: TroyD]
Ian Offline

Registered: 03/13/01
Posts: 899

I will start this answer to your “question” with a conclusion; you need not concern yourself with the measurement phenomenon known as comb filtering. Since we produce multi-driver systems here at Axiom we have put much research into understanding the impact of comb filtering on the real world listening environment. There are huge benefits to using multiple drivers, especially in the area of being able to produce large dynamic range without distortion, so it is not something that should be casually thrown out of your design options. Certainly, on the surface, if you were to only look at the measurements taken by the microphone of comb filtering, without any further research, you would probably decide it is something that must be avoided. But this would be an over simplistic and very counter productive way to actually design a great sounding loudspeaker. It would be akin to simply taking a bunch of measurements and then go about drawing theoretical conclusions based on those measurements without feeling the need to do any real world testing of your theories. This will result in some great marketing propaganda and some great discussion material in which to back up your theories; but it would not result in a great sounding loudspeaker. The proper approach is to go through the somewhat painstaking process of understanding each measurement and its effect on the final listening experience, paying careful attention to the thresholds of audibility and the interrelationship with other measurements that may hold a greater significance to the end listening performance.

So let’s take a look at comb filtering in this light. First off comb filtering can be measured any time two drive units are playing the same frequency and the microphone is not located exactly equidistant between them. For example, if we take a standard stereo pair of speakers located say 8 feet apart, any movement of the microphone off centre, even as small as ½ inch, will show the affects of comb filtering. For more detail on this you can check out our newsletter article on comb filtering . In order to avoid comb filtering occurring in our listening environment not only would we have to restrict ourselves to loudspeakers that only used one driver per frequency allocation, which would have huge detrimental affects on the ability to achieve great dynamic range, but we would have to restrict ourselves to only having one speaker in the room, in other words return to listening in mono through one speaker. Given the obvious enormous downside to doing this perhaps first we should review the real world results of comb filtering in our listening environment before rushing off and getting rid of all our speakers save one.

One of the more revealing tests we performed in our lab was to set up a double blind listening test where we had three identical speakers, in this case we used the M2, and compared only playing the single speaker in the middle against playing the two on the outside simultaneously. We conducted this test in two separate sessions; one with the three speakers placed side by side, which gave us about a 15” separation between the drivers playing simultaneously, and one with the two outer speakers placed one meter to each side of the centre speaker. The amplitude response was preset so the two speakers had the same output as the single speaker and only a mono source was used. Not to wander off into a completely different subject, but it is worth at least noting that these sorts of tests must be done double blind. Any attempt to do them sighted or with the participants knowing what is on test will result in the participants who understand the effects of comb filtering on the measurements becoming biased in their judgment. This holds true for virtually all tests in audio and we have proved this over and over.

The results of that test were a clear winner for the widely separated pair and a slight nod for the closely positioned pair; the single speaker lost in both tests. The moral of the story here is to be careful when interpreting your measurement results and falling into the trap of thinking a microphone is giving you the exact results that will be perceived by two ears and a brain. In the case of comb filtering such a simplistic approach to loudspeaker design would cause the designer to throw out all the benefits of multi-driver systems to gain nothing. Forget about having to choose between taking a small degradation in one area in order to achieve a much larger benefit in another, which would also be a valid design decision; in the case of avoiding comb filtering you have to give up a very large benefit to gain absolutely nothing. I think one of the most eloquent comments ever made regarding the dangers of taking microphone measurements for granted was by Dr. Floyd Toole in one of his papers written back when we were doing our research at the NRC; “A measurement microphone performs a simple transduction of the pressure summation at the diaphragm location, without regard for the direction or timing of the incident sounds. Two ears and a brain, however, are rather more elaborate in their processing”.
Ian Colquhoun
President & Chief Engineer

#284928 - 01/02/10 12:28 PM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: Ian]
SirQuack Offline
shareholder in the making

Registered: 01/29/04
Posts: 13369
Loc: Iowa
M80s-VP180-QS8s-EP600-2xEP350 Denon3808 Outlaw7700
(M22-OWM22-VP100)-all in storage

#284930 - 01/02/10 01:10 PM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: SirQuack]
SRoode Offline

Registered: 03/20/08
Posts: 1266
Loc: Fishers, Indiana, USA
Thank you very much Ian for the considerate and very informative respose. I always think it quite odd that combing effects are brought up today, when most home theater setups consist of 5 or more speakers positioned all around the listener, all of which reproduce the full spectrum of frequencies, more or less. As you stated, the only way to truly rid yourself of the combing effect is to have a single speaker with a single driver for that frequency. Nobody would want to listen to that.
2 M80s, 1 VP180, 4 QS8s, 2 EP800s, 4 Algonquins, 2 M3 VaSSallos, 1 AxiomAir N3

#284931 - 01/02/10 01:33 PM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: SRoode]
Adrian Offline

Registered: 12/27/08
Posts: 6772
Loc: It's all about the location.
Ideed, line array speakers have become common with the emergence of the home theatre. Thank's for the very informative post Ian.
Half of communication is listening. You can't listen with your mouth.

#284936 - 01/02/10 02:10 PM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: Adrian]
onn Offline

Registered: 02/28/08
Posts: 971
Loc: Edmonton Alberta
Thanks for the great information Ian.
My system

#284937 - 01/02/10 02:12 PM Re: From HT Shack a question maybe for Ian or Alan [Re: Ian]
chesseroo Offline

Registered: 05/13/02
Posts: 5117
Loc: western canada
I like a post that explains the details behind the conclusion. Without that, most people just think you might be making it up.
Comb filtering has no effect?
Prove it.
Ok then, here's what we did...

Nice experiment Ian.
I want to be a test listener in one of these some day, once Axiom takes their show on the road across all Canadian cities for some countrywide marketing and polling demonstration.
"Those who preach the myths of audio are ignorant of truth."

Page 4 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

Moderator:  alan, Amie, Andrew, axiomadmin, Brent, Debbie, Ian, Jc 

Home  |  Corporate Info  |  Products  |  Message Board  |  FAQs  |  Warranty  |  Site Map  |  Privacy Statement   |  Contact Us

©2015 Colquhoun Audio Laboratories Limited
All Rights Reserved.