The Moxi is supposedly similar to Tivo. I have not seen either first hand.

I used to have Dishnet. Then HD rolled out and I would have had to put up a second dish, one 40" and one 60". I checked into DirectTV but their satellite could not be seen from my home do to my home town being surrounded by 3000' mountains. They may have service now, I should probably check into that.

Normally, cable has better signal quality than sat, but things have changed and that might not be the case anymore.