Thanks for all the great recommendations. I think I'll start out giving some on the onkyos a try and look at the Marantz tuner next. Of course, if I do find a nice used tuner that does the trick I may just leave it on the one elusive station and use my regular tuner/receiver for the rest - as long as I don't have to get out of my listening chair!
Thanks again. I'll let everyone know how my search goes, but I don't think I'll get the $ up for a month or so.