Originally Posted By: fredk

So, like me, you don't like what makes a good Scotch what it is. smile


Not so sure it is a prerequisite or not, if price is a deciding factor... I did have some 25 YO stuff that I really liked (Bunnahabhain). It had just a very subtle hint of peat and smoke. Enough to know it was Scotch style Whisky, but only enough. I brought it back on the plane last time I was in the UK. Stupid expensive though. I'd rather have some Canadian.