Axiom Home Page Forums General Discussion Home Theater 2900, 2910 or 3910.......Need help

Testing Day 2:

I decided to try some other movies and so far I have only tested them on the 2910 via DVI. I think my TV is calibrated pretty well because after running through some video tests on a calibration disc my brother let me borrow, I didn't have do anything major.

I am still torn between the two players... I think after I finish posting this, I am going to watch the indentical scenes i just watched on the 2910 on the 2900.

I think the worse part is going to be trying to take back the 2910 to the store. Those guys have been so helpful and I am going to feel bad taking it back.... But, oh well...

More to come later...

I axiously await the results. Though I'd still be interested to hear how the DVI pans out with a front projector. From what I hear, this is when DVI is more of a desired feature.

So, you gonna buy a front projector so we can test that too

First of all, I would not consider myself that much of a pro on what REALLY makes a picture good or bad. I did spend 7 years in the industry. BUT.....It was with Circuit City and I have not worked for them in almost 4 years. So, technology has changed dramatically.

After going back and forth with the two players.. I think I am really starting to like how the DVI does on my TV. I have heard several people say that it doesn't make a difference, but I was EXTREMELY impressed on how it did with the 3 original star wars movies. Especially in Return of the Jedi when Han and Luke are being sent out to "die" by Jabba. The shot of the sand and blue sky was pretty awesome. The 2910 allows you to switch from DVI and Component and I kept switching back and forth. The Component even looks real good on the 2910. The 2900 seemed to have more "bleeding" than I would like. I am not sure if that is the proper way of explaining it or not.

I am going to go down and watch my DAWGS whoop up on Georgia Tech on HDTV before going to a family party tonight. Then, when I get home tonight, I will look at it one more time... but I think I am leaning towards the 2910 now.

Ray, I know you probably want to ring my neck... but everybody has there on opinion and likes... I do appreciate everything you recommended....

Click back later!

Absolutely no neck wringing happening here!!!

The whole thing about this crazy HT hobby, aside for the expense is to end up with something YOU like. Subjectivity is the driver and pleasure is the desired state. The way you have tackled this is perfect and when you are done, you won't have any nagging doubts. Grab the one you like and be happy. I'm just pleased that the whole discussion and testing things happened since other folks may also gain some knowledge from it.

just when I think everything is okay with my system....My HD keeps cutting in and out. I changed the component cables today and I wonder if that is it.... OH WELL..

The good news is, I think my local cable company was having some problems last night because my cousin was having problems with his HD as well.

The decision has been made and the 2900 is packed up and waiting to be dropped off at UPS tomorrow morning. I haven't put the 2910 into the entertainment center because right now I have the silver version and the manager ordered me one in black and it should be in tomorrow or Tuesday.

Once I get everything hooked up, I am going to take some pictures and let everybody see..

Thanks for all the help and I hope I do not have any problems with my new DVD player..:)

Thanks for taking us along on the journey, Jeff. Good stuff.

I want to say thank you too, I went on a hunch and bought the 2910 myself. Glad to see you liked it also, I cant wait to get mine. (I should have mine by the 7th.) At the moment I am using a Samsung DVD player, although it is brand new, I don’t think it is going to hold a candle to the 2910.

Thanks again for the review, take care.

Outstanding solution. Now you'll be totally pleased with the end result. Thanks for keeping us on board as you went through the testing.

Ray,

You talked me into in. I ordered the 2900 as a Xmas gift. I hope the recipient will be very happy with it. I have one question, for anyone who owns one. Are there any disc types this deck won't play?