I agree on the "pick your poison" mentality to appliances, so I can only offer that the features of ice and water were something I also wanted in a new model.

After going through the trouble of buying a S/S with ice and water a few years back (and having the water supply run for it), I found those features to be utterly frustrating and useless. So much so that the next purchase was stand alone fridge and freezer combination and have been happy ever since!