Previous Topic
Index
Get free, friendly, expert advice call 1-888-352-9466 or email
- My Account
- Worldwide Shipping
-
Recently added item(s) ×
You have no items in your shopping cart.
You are not logged in. [Log In]
Forums » General Discussion » Hearing Things » Does all power amp sounded the same?
|
|
#366554 - 02/14/12 04:28 AM
Does all power amp sounded the same?
|
|
local 
Registered: 07/24/09 Posts: 287 Loc: Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia |
Does all power amp sounded the same?
DO we need more power to drive our belove Axiom? I think many of us asked these question before and some might agreed and some don't. Me and a few audio fanatic (and bass nuts) did a power amp test at my place, comparing 3 different amp for the front 3 channel of M60v2 and VP150v2 The amp are:- 1. Emotiva XPA-3 (200W/ch) 2. Odessey HT-3 SE (150W/ch) 3. Anthem PVA5 (125W/ch)  All of us (6 of us) agreed that the Odessey sound best with great dynamic and much more refine sound and detail. The anthem have a better detail than XPA3 but due to it lesser power, the dynamic of the sound somehow are a lot flatter than the other two. And thus not good for movies. The XPA 3 have the same dynamic (with lots of headroom) as compared with the HT3, but the sound is more metalic and edgy and also lose out the detial to the Anthem and HT3. And yes, we agreed that amp do sound differently and we need as much power as possible to get most out of the speakers. We tested scene from Star Wars' "Pod Race" and many concert songs. Now, please don't fight :p |
| Top | |
#366556 - 02/14/12 05:53 AM
Re: Does all power amp sounded the same?
[Re: mpyw]
|
|
|
shareholder in the making Registered: 05/11/02 Posts: 10631 |
Michael, the facts of audio technology, which would be confirmed in a properly controlled blind listening test, are that there's no audible difference in either the quality or quantity of power available from those three amplifiers.
_________________________
----------------------------------- Enjoy the music, not the equipment. |
| Top | |
|
#366565 - 02/14/12 08:46 AM
Re: Does all power amp sounded the same?
[Re: mpyw]
|
|
|
shareholder in the making 
Registered: 05/03/03 Posts: 18044 Loc: NoVA |
Oh, there's going to be a fight.
_________________________
I am the Doctor, and THIS... is my SPOON! |
| Top | |
|
#366566 - 02/14/12 08:47 AM
Re: Does all power amp sounded the same?
[Re: mpyw]
|
|
|
shareholder in the making 
Registered: 09/27/04 Posts: 11444 Loc: Central NH |
Get out the canned deer and popcorn!
_________________________
::::::: No disrespect to Axiom, but my favorite woofer is my yellow lab ::::::: |
| Top | |
|
#366569 - 02/14/12 09:11 AM
Re: Does all power amp sounded the same?
[Re: mpyw]
|
|
|
frequent flier Registered: 01/17/11 Posts: 16 Loc: Muscat, Oman |
I thought I heard some metallic sound during the iron giant. Must be the XPA-3. It did feel 'edgy'.
_________________________
Tariq M80v2 - VP180 - S:QS8 - SB:QS8 - SWide:QS8 Denon 4311 + XPA-3 Sub: Dual SVS Ultra-13 |
| Top | |
|
#366571 - 02/14/12 09:27 AM
Re: Does all power amp sounded the same?
[Re: Tariq]
|
|
|
axiomite 
Registered: 02/05/06 Posts: 6469 Loc: Fredericksburg, Virginia |
Originally Posted By: Tariq I thought I heard some metallic sound during the iron giant. Makes sense, no? 
_________________________
Bears, beets, Battlestar Galactica. |
| Top | |
|
#366572 - 02/14/12 09:30 AM
Re: Does all power amp sounded the same?
[Re: mpyw]
|
|
|
axiomite 
Registered: 08/05/09 Posts: 6015 Loc: Milky Way Galaxy |
I love the new avatar. Got a laugh out of that one.
_________________________
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?...amp;usp=sharing |
| Top | |
|
#366575 - 02/14/12 09:42 AM
Re: Does all power amp sounded the same?
[Re: mpyw]
|
|
|
connoisseur Registered: 02/08/04 Posts: 1863 |
Originally Posted By: mpyw And yes, we agreed that amp do sound differently and we need as much power as possible to get most out of the speakers. See, John, I've been right all along!..... :~) It says so right here on the interweb... |
| Top | |
|
#366588 - 02/14/12 10:51 AM
Re: Does all power amp sounded the same?
[Re: mpyw]
|
|
|
connoisseur 
Registered: 09/19/08 Posts: 4116 Loc: Porch,enjoying Bombay Sapphire |
Originally Posted By: mpyw Does all power amp sounded the same? DO we need more power to drive our belove Axiom? I think many of us asked these question before and some might agreed and some don't. Me and a few audio fanatic (and bass nuts) did a power amp test at my place, comparing 3 different amp for the front 3 channel of M60v2 and VP150v2 The amp are:- 1. Emotiva XPA-3 (200W/ch) 2. Odessey HT-3 SE (150W/ch) 3. Anthem PVA5 (125W/ch) All of us (6 of us) agreed that the Odessey sound best with great dynamic and much more refine sound and detail. The anthem have a better detail than XPA3 but due to it lesser power, the dynamic of the sound somehow are a lot flatter than the other two. And thus not good for movies. The XPA 3 have the same dynamic (with lots of headroom) as compared with the HT3, but the sound is more metalic and edgy and also lose out the detial to the Anthem and HT3. And yes, we agreed that amp do sound differently and we need as much power as possible to get most out of the speakers. We tested scene from Star Wars' "Pod Race" and many concert songs. Now, please don't fight :p Good stuff. For another get together, test out some different brands of AVR's with different speaker/room correction programs. Use them as pre-amps if possible with external amplification with the auto calibration and equalization engaged on the AVR. It would be interesting to see which one would come out on top in your test.
_________________________
I’m armed and I’m drinking. You don’t want to listen to advice from me, amigo. -Max Payne |
| Top | |
|
#366589 - 02/14/12 10:56 AM
Re: Does all power amp sounded the same?
[Re: mpyw]
|
|
|
aficionado Registered: 07/03/08 Posts: 852 Loc: Toronto |
Considering the fact that all three of these amps have a different power output, until you somehow, can get them to output at "exactly" equal moderate volume for your source material and can instantaneously switch between them, any realistic comparison is going to be difficult. I dunno, but, it always comes back to the same old story in these comparisons that if one of them is even slightly louder than the other, to the human ear it is going to be perceived as sounding "better" or at minimum, "different". For that reason alone and considering that this is such mature technology, I, personally, have never bought the idea that there is a "real" audible difference between various brands.
Edited by casey01 (02/14/12 11:04 AM) |
| Top | |
