I ended up calling Digikey and talking to a tech guy. They were able to cross reference the cap I have with a different cap they had in stock. Slightly different, same manufacture. Nichicon UFW2A102MHD

http://www.digikey.com/product-search/en?keywords=5%20493-3185-ND

The tech suggested I use a hot-glue gun, and that's what he uses. Just make sure I don't use a corrosive or conductive glue.