Funny, I interpreted his post as a throw a glove in your face type challenge to those of us on the, shall we say, scientific side of things. I thought my response was fairly measured. I think it's important to remember that tone of voice is not available as an input in writing...
In answer to your question, yes, I would. I would want to hear it back to back immediately (if that was possible), see if scientific measurements by an independant board indicated differences in the frequency response, etc, and see if someone else heard the same thing I did. If no to any of these questions, it's likely in my head.
