I thought it was probably a tie with some real zingers thrown in by Cheney. He didn't need a win. He only needed to stop the bleeding. Edward's said some really stupid things such as how "we have too many lawsuits in this country" - absurd coming from an ambulance chaser.

His bringing up of Cheney's lesbian daughter was uncalled and displays horrible character on the part of Edwards. Edwards almost came off as a used car salesman to me.

There wasn't much substance from either side in terms of what they would do for the country. They were too busy attacking each other. But man, bringing up the man's daughter was way out of line and totally classless. I'm pleased with Cheney's response to that.